Uber and Lyft ordered to classify workers as employees in California
By Mon, Aug 10, 2020
A judge ruled Monday that Uber Technologies Inc. and Lyft Inc. must classify their drivers as employees due to a new California law, a decision that threatens the business models of the ride-hailing giants and other gig-economy companies.
California Attorney General Xavier Becerra and the city attorneys of San Francisco, Los Angeles and San Diego sued the San Francisco-based companies, asking a judge for a mandatory injunction ordering the companies to comply immediately with a new state law over worker classification, which became effective Jan. 1. Uber UBER, -1.91% is challenging the constitutionality of the law, known as Assembly Bill 5 or AB5, and in a hearing last week argued against an immediate injunction pending a trial in that lawsuit. The ride-hailing giants and other gig companies have succeeded in putting an initiative on the state ballot in November that offers worker concessions but would exempt them from having to comply with the new California law.
In granting the injunction, Judge Ethan Schulman of the Superior Court in San Francisco wrote in his decision: “The People have amply demonstrated a reasonable probability of prevailing on their claim that Defendants are misclassifying their drivers.”
What comes next will be closely watched in a case with the potential for huge repercussions. Uber and Lyft LYFT, +2.84% told the judge in the injunction hearing Thursday that an injunction would be unprecedented and will affect hundreds of thousands of drivers. Schulman stayed the injunction for 10 days pending an appeal, but legal experts say the companies are likely to ask for an extension.
“I would think the companies have a big mountain to climb,” said William Gould, emeritus professor at Stanford Law School and a former chief of the National Labor Relations Board. “Their sky-will-fall arguments are more appropriately addressed to the legislature than the judiciary.”
Uber and Lyft were quick to say they intend to appeal.
“The court’s ruling is stayed for a minimum of 10 days, and we plan to file an immediate emergency appeal on behalf of California drivers,” an Uber spokesman told MarketWatch in an email.
“Drivers do not want to be employees, full stop,” a Lyft spokesman wrote. “We’ll immediately appeal this ruling and continue to fight for their independence. Ultimately, we believe this issue will be decided by California voters and that they will side with drivers.”
Shares in Uber and Lyft drops in after-hours trading Monday, showing declines of 1% to 2%.
About the Author
Trade Stocks was specifically created as a resource that traders and investors can rely on for accurate and timely financial news and insights. Our team of industry experts brings you the into you need when you need it. That’s why hundreds of thousands of traders and investors trust us to provide them with the financial education, support, and resources that they can count on to help them move closer to their financial goals.
